Income Tax Scrutiny Under Section 143(2): Simple Guide

Introduction

For Indian business leaders, a notice under Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act can feel like an unexpected audit alarm. While the word “scrutiny” may sound intimidating, it is essentially a detailed verification of the information you have already disclosed in your Income Tax Return (ITR). This guide demystifies the entire process, equips you with a step‑by‑step response plan, and highlights best practices to keep your compliance risk low.

What Exactly Is Section 143(2)?

Section 143(2) empowers the Assessing Officer (AO) to re‑examine a filed return after the initial processing under Section 143(1). The AO may issue a notice if any of the following are observed:

• Discrepancies between the return and information available with the department (e.g., TDS/TCS mismatches).
• Unusually high cash receipts or deposits.
• Claims of deductions or exemptions that appear excessive.
• Any indication of tax evasion or concealment of income.

Understanding these triggers helps you anticipate and prepare for a possible scrutiny.

Common Triggers for Scrutiny – A Quick Reference

The Scrutiny Lifecycle – Step‑by‑Step

1. Selection: The AO’s computer‑aided system flags the return based on the triggers above.
2. Notice Issuance: A formal notice (Form 31) is sent, specifying the points of enquiry.
3. Response Period: Typically 15‑30 days. Extensions may be granted on valid grounds.
4. Document Submission: You must furnish the requested documents, such as bank statements, invoices, contracts, and reconciliation statements.
5. Verification: The AO reviews the submitted evidence. Additional queries may be raised.
6. Assessment Order: If satisfied, the return is accepted. Otherwise, a revised assessment (including additional tax, interest, and penalties) is issued.

How to Respond Effectively

Responding promptly and accurately can turn a potential penalty into a simple clarification. Follow this checklist:

• Read the notice carefully: Identify each point of enquiry and the documents requested.
• Gather supporting evidence: Use original invoices, bank‑reconciliation statements, GST returns, and statutory registers.
• Prepare a response draft: Address each query point‑wise, citing the relevant law (e.g., Section 44AB for audit, Section 80C for deductions).
• Seek professional assistance: A chartered accountant can ensure the response is legally sound and complete.
• Submit within the deadline: Late submissions attract penalties of up to Rs. 10,000 per day.

Potential Consequences of Non‑Compliance

Ignoring or delaying a 143(2) notice can lead to severe financial and reputational fallout:

• Penalties: Up to 200% of the tax shortfall for concealment, or Rs. 5,000‑Rs. 10,000 per day for delayed response.
• Interest: Simple interest at 1% per month on the assessed tax.
• Prosecution: In extreme cases of willful tax evasion, imprisonment up to 2 years.
• Operational disruption: Audits may freeze bank accounts or delay credit facilities.

Best Practices to Minimise Scrutiny Risk

While scrutiny is a statutory right of the department, you can lower the probability of being flagged by adopting robust compliance habits:

1. Maintain comprehensive books of accounts: Use accounting software that integrates with GST and TDS modules.
2. Reconcile bank statements monthly: Ensure that cash deposits match sales records.
3. File accurate TDS/TCS returns: Cross‑verify Form 26AS before filing the ITR.
4. Document all deductions: Keep original bills for depreciation, Section 80C investments, and business expenses.
5. Conduct internal audits: Periodic internal audit can surface anomalies early. Learn more about our internal audit services.
6. Engage a tax advisor for complex returns: Especially for businesses with cross‑border transactions or multiple subsidiaries.

When to Call a Specialist

If any of the following apply, it is prudent to involve a tax specialist immediately:

• Multiple queries in the notice covering different financial years.
• Large tax adjustments (> Rs. 10 lakhs) are proposed.
• You lack a complete set of supporting documents.
• Previous scrutiny resulted in penalties or litigation.

Our income‑tax litigation representation team has a proven track record of negotiating settlements and defending clients before the Assessing Officer.

Case‑Study Insight (Generic)

Consider a mid‑size manufacturing firm that received a 143(2) notice for alleged excess depreciation. By presenting a detailed depreciation schedule, asset purchase invoices, and a valuation report prepared by a certified valuer, the firm was able to substantiate its claim and avoid any additional tax liability. The key takeaway: **pre‑emptive documentation** saves time and money.

Call to Action

Facing a scrutiny notice? Don’t let it derail your business growth. Our seasoned tax professionals can:

• Analyse the notice and draft a precise response.
• Gather and organise all required documents.
• Represent you before the Assessing Officer.
• Negotiate penalties and interest where permissible.

Take the first step today:

WhatsApp Us Now Email Our Experts

Conclusion

Section 143(2) scrutiny is a routine, yet critical, compliance checkpoint. By understanding why the department initiates scrutiny, responding within the stipulated period, and maintaining impeccable records, you can safeguard your business from costly penalties. When in doubt, partner with a trusted tax advisory firm to navigate the process confidently.

For deeper insights into operational excellence, explore our guide on process consulting for business efficiency. Additionally, learn how our scrutiny handling service can take the burden off your shoulders.

Frequently Asked Questions